City profile
Bay Shore, NY
Nassau County · Population 31,683
Bay Shore is a town in Nassau County, NY with about 31,683 residents and a typical home value near $492,000. It is 40 miles from New York City, NY, which shapes its climate, healthcare access and amenities.
Climate
Climate type
Four seasons
Winter avg
35°F
Summer avg
77°F
Sunny days / yr
230
Home prices & cost of living
Median home price
$492,200
Typical monthly housing
$3,305
Cost of living (100 = U.S.)
144
Taxes
- Property tax
- 1.54%
- State income tax (top)
- 10.9%
- Social Security
- Not taxed
- Pensions
- Partly exempt
- Sales tax (state + avg. local)
- 8.53%
FEMA natural hazard risk
Relatively High · county score 97/100
Top hazards: Winter weather, Coastal flooding, Riverine flooding
Nearest major airport
28 mi to John F. Kennedy International Airport (JFK)
Political lean (2024 county vote)
Competitive / purple · 48% Democratic / 52% Republican
Community
Population
31,683
Black population
13.8%
County
Nassau County
Detailed crime figures are available for our 201 hand-researched cities.
2025–2026 trends
2026 market trends
- ▸More retirees are leaving NY than arriving, mostly over cost
- ▸Home prices are still rising in 2026 — good for long-term value, less room to negotiate
- ▸Climate/cost risks to check: winter storms, high taxes
Highlights
- About 31,683 residents
- Typical home value about $492,000
- 40 miles from New York City, NY
Trade-offs
- Scores for this place are estimated from Census data and the nearest major city
Figures are estimates from public sources (see How we match). Verify before making decisions.